4,000-Year-Old Skeletons: A Mother’s Last Embrace

October 15, 2024

The mystery behind the 4,000-year-old skeletons: a mother trying to protect her son

Images of skeletons from the Lajia site in China’s Qinghai province are captivating. The painstaking excavation and pedestaling of the bones reveal adults and children in a 4,000-year-old embrace. But while these images have caught the media’s attention today, the archaeological site has been excavated since 1999 by archaeologists primarily from the Institute of Archaeology of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences and the Qinghai Provincial Institute of Antiquity and Archaeology.

By Kristina Killgrove

The Lajia site is associated with the Qijia culture, dating from the late Neolithic to the early Bronze Age, and is located in the Guanting Basin of the upper Yellow River. This site has yielded everything from cave-like houses to pottery kilns to preserved millet noodle remains. The spectacular preservation appears to be the result of a catastrophic event: around 1900 BC, an earthquake struck the area, triggering landslides. In a 2013 paper in The Holocene , Chun Chang Huang and colleagues explained that “huge mudflows suddenly buried and destroyed dwellings and killed women and children in their homes.” But these mudflows, though triggered by an earthquake, were “partly created by early settlers” through “soil erosion, massive weathering, and debris accumulation on hillsides, greatly intensified by human disturbance of the landscape by shrub removal as early as 6,000 years ago to 3,950 years before present.”

The mystery behind the 4,000-year-old skeletons: a mother trying to protect her son

Of course, my interest was piqued by the image of the skeletons of an adult and a child embracing, particularly since the title referred to a mother and child (since DNA is the only way to tell the sex of young children). The skeletons’ main publication (in English, that is), is a 2007 paper in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology by Shi-Zhu Gao and colleagues at Jilin University in China dealing with the DNA analysis of the 16 skeletons from two houses flooded by landslides.

Gao and his colleagues were interested in whether the 16 individuals were related, and looked at mitochondrial DNA, which is passed down the maternal line. “Twelve [DNA] sequences from individuals found in one house were assigned to only five haplotypes,” they write, “consistent with possible close kinship.” The two skeletons — an adult woman in her 30s and a 3- or 4-year-old boy — whose image has captivated the media today are supposed to be mother and son, but many media outlets refer to “mother and son.” The only way to tell the sex of a subadult is through DNA analysis, but the 2007 publication contains no information on the sex of the child.

Even more interesting, however, were the DNA results from these two individuals. Gao and colleagues write that “the two mtDNA sequences from individuals from F3 (one of the houses) differ from each other at five nucleotide positions. Although these two subjects may be genetically linked by a mother/son (or daughter) relationship, this result unambiguously excludes kinship through the maternal lineage.” They further explain that these individuals and their mtDNA haplotypes were different from individuals from F4 (the other house). A patrilineal relationship remains a possibility since their skeletal remains were found close together.”

There was one group that represented a mother-child pair based on DNA analysis: a woman in her 20s and a 1- to 2-year-old child from house F4. I don’t believe this is the pair illustrated in the image circulated above for two reasons: the child’s skull in that photo is more consistent with a 3- to 4-year-old child, and based on the diagram in the 2007 paper and the image below, the photos show two different adult-child pairs. I couldn’t find a clear image that represents the biological mother-child pair, although the photo above shows most of the groups from house F4. Based on my cross-referencing of the 2007 paper with these images, the biological mother-child pair is represented by the skeletons at the bottom.

The mystery behind the 4,000-year-old skeletons: a mother trying to protect her son

Review: Top 10 Cloud Services in the USA Cloud computing has transformed how businesses operate, offering scalable, secure, and cost-effective solutions for storage, computing, and application management. The U.S. leads the global cloud market, with providers delivering innovative services tailored to startups, enterprises, and everything in between. Below is a comprehensive review of the top 10 cloud service providers in the USA for 2025, based on market share, service offerings, and customer feedback. Amazon Web Services (AWS)AWS dominates with a 31% global market share, generating $24.2 billion in Q4 2023 revenue. It offers over 200 services, including compute (EC2), storage (S3), AI (SageMaker), and analytics. AWS’s 33 regions and 105 availability zones ensure low latency and high reliability. Its pay-as-you-go pricing starts at ~$0.0832/hour for a t3.large instance (2 vCPUs, 8GB RAM). Ideal for businesses needing scalability and cutting-edge AI tools. Microsoft AzureAzure holds a 24% market share and is the fastest-growing major provider, with 30% revenue growth in 2023. It offers 200+ services, including IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS, with strengths in AI, IoT, and enterprise integration. Azure’s pricing for a 2 vCPU, 8GB RAM instance (D2s v3) starts at ~$0.096/hour. Its hybrid cloud solutions and Microsoft ecosystem make it a top choice for enterprises. Google Cloud Platform (GCP)GCP, with an 11.5% market share, excels in AI, machine learning (TensorFlow, BigQuery), and data analytics. It offers 150+ services across 24 regions and 73 zones. Pricing for an e2-standard-2 instance (2 vCPUs, 8GB RAM) starts at ~$0.070/hour, with up to 57% discounts for committed use. GCP is favored by data-driven businesses and developers. IBM CloudIBM Cloud provides IaaS, PaaS, and SaaS with a focus on enterprise-grade security, AI (Watson), and hybrid/multi-cloud deployments. It serves industries like healthcare and finance, offering 170+ services. Pricing varies, but its pay-as-you-go model is competitive. IBM’s strong partner ecosystem and AIOps solutions enhance business transformation. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI)Oracle Cloud is gaining traction with its high-performance computing and database services. It offers cost-effective pricing, with a free tier and discounts for committed use. OCI’s focus on enterprise applications, like ERP and CRM, makes it ideal for large organizations. Its global network includes 40+ regions. DigitalOceanDigitalOcean targets startups and developers with simple, affordable cloud hosting. Plans start at $2.50/month for 0.5GB RAM, 10GB storage, and 1 vCPU. Its managed databases (PostgreSQL, MySQL) and monitoring tools ensure reliability. DigitalOcean’s free credits and Hatch program support early-stage businesses. VMware CloudVMware, now under Broadcom, specializes in multi-cloud and hybrid cloud solutions. It supports AWS, Azure, and GCP, offering consistent management across environments. VMware’s virtualization expertise and low-cost migration tools make it a top pick for enterprises modernizing data centers. SalesforceSalesforce focuses on cloud-based CRM and customer service solutions. Its Service Cloud automates workflows and integrates with AI for personalized customer experiences. With 1.5 million users, it’s a leader for businesses prioritizing customer engagement. Pricing is subscription-based, tailored to business size. CloudflareCloudflare is a CDN and security-focused provider, offering DDoS protection, DNS, and content delivery. Its user-friendly interface and integrations with WordPress and Shopify appeal to businesses needing fast, secure web performance. Pricing includes a free tier and pay-as-you-go plans. Linode (Akamai) Linode, acquired by Akamai, offers developer-friendly cloud hosting with transparent pricing and a free tier. It integrates with Akamai’s CDN for enhanced performance. Plans start at $5/month for 1GB RAM, 25GB storage, and 1 vCPU. Linode is ideal for SMBs and tech-savvy users. Choosing the Right Provider Selecting a cloud provider depends on your needs: AWS, Azure, and GCP dominate for scalability and enterprise solutions; DigitalOcean and Linode cater to startups; Salesforce excels in CRM; and Cloudflare prioritizes web performance. Compare pricing, scalability, and security features. Check reviews on platforms like Gartner or Forbes Cloud 100 for insights. As cloud spending grows (projected at $591.8 billion in 2023), ensure your choice aligns with long-term goals.